APPENDIX: THE TAFF WARS
As it had been in the late-1950s, TAFF was the focus of a lot of acrimony in
1984. The race that year was between D West and me. We drew in the UK, but I won
the North American vote. The North American administrator at that time was
Avedon Carol and during her TAFF trip to the UK in 1983 (she was Fan Guest of
Honour at ALBACON) we'd developed a close personal relationship, one which was
far from being secret. Over in Puerto Rico, Richard Bergeron -- a fervent
supporter of West during the race -- chose to believe that Avedon had unduly
influenced people to vote on my behalf and, taking an offhand comment about him
in one of her fanzines as a jumping off point, launched into a series of attacks
on her in both fanzines and in private correspondence. Americans such as Ted
White and Patrick & Teresa Nielsen Hayden, and Britons such as Chuck Harris
and Dave Langford (a group including some of West's nominators), wrote letters
arguing that he was mistaken but were unable to move him. A feud was brewing and
it started to come to the boil as I was beginning my TAFF trip across the US.
Seeing this, Dave Locke and Jackie Causgrove of Cincinnatti, fans who had had
grievances of their own with the administration of the fund during previous
races, entered the fray in support of Bergeron. D West, Avedon's supposed
victim, thought Bergeron's charges against her groundless and wrote an open
letter dismissing them out of hand, but it did nothing to stop the feud. By this
point it had taken on a life of its own. Even so the feud, though the cause of
much stress among those caught up in it, aroused little interest among British
fans as a whole since most of the action was occurring in the pages of private
correspondence. That all changed when the 1985 TAFF race was drawn into the
conflict.
Usually those wanting to run in a TAFF race make their intentions known long
before the nomination period opens and there are rarely eleventh hour entries,
but in the 1985 race there was one. As the nomination period was drawing to a
close, the administrators began to receive nominations for Martha Beck. Since
one of her nominators missed the deadline date by a week, Beck failed to make
the ballot, but that was not the end of the matter. In early November '84,
copies of a 'Martha Beck for TAFF' flyer that was being circulated in the
American Midwest by Jackie Causgrove were 'leaked' to Linda Krawecke
Pickersgill. This document urged local fans to vote for Beck by writing in her
name on their TAFF ballots, and called her 'the Midwestern candidate'. (Of the
other candidates, Rich Coad lived on the West Coast and the Nielsen Haydens on
the East Coast, though none of them were actually from these areas originally.)
TAFF has never operated on the basis of the candidates representing any
particular region of the sending country but there were reasons why Midwestern
fans were peculiarly susceptible to such an appeal. During the business session
of the 1984 Worldcon, Ben Yalow, an East Coast fan, had suggested that for the
purposes of Worldcon rotation the US in future be split into two zones rather
than the current three "... in order to eliminate wimpy bids". This
quote got somewhat garbled on the grapevine and word went round that an attempt
was being made by East and West Coast fans to squeeze out 'the Wimpy Zone', ie
... the Midwest. Much was made of 'the Wimpy Zone' in literature for the Martha
Beck write-in campaign, as if a Beck victory would somehow show fans from the
coastal regions that the Midwest was still a force to be reckoned with and not
so wimpy after all. Needless to say, this appeal to US regional chauvinism
didn't go down at all well in the UK since British fans didn't give a damn about
such matters. Indeed, they viewed the attempt to swamp the ballot with a massive
Midwestern vote as an attempt to disenfranchise them, to render their vote and
their voice in this race irrelevant, particularly since no-one involved in the
Beck campaign ever directly informed British fandom at large about it. Beck was
completely unknown in the UK and there was no attempt made to start a campaign
over here or even to make copies of the flyer available. Noting that candidates
Patrick and Teresa Nielsen Hayden had strongly supported administrator Avedon
Carol in the still-raging feud, and that Jackie Causgrove had supported Richard
Bergeron, many found it impossible to believe that Causgrove's campaign was
unconnected with the feud. A British response to all this was inevitable, and it
soon materialised.
Linda Krawecke Pickersgill was appalled by the campaign and determined to do
something about it. With then-husband Greg, she put together a petition that
spelled out what was happening and the importance of taking a stand against it.
"It is vital that we make our voices heard even though our votes may now
seem to count for nothing", read the petition, "... we must register
our protests with the TAFF administration over the way our vote is being
disregarded". The petition argued its case eloquently enough, but it was
reading the copy of the 'Martha Beck for TAFF' flyer attached to it that
convinced many to sign. "If the majority of British TAFF voters protest the
use of British TAFF funds to support candidates who have no contact or interest
in British fandom", concluded the petition, "there will be a mandate
for the freezing of such funds until a more acceptable solution is reached".
Such was the offense the Beck campaign had caused that copies of the petition
rolled in from all parts of the UK, the signatories including most of the
best-known fans of the day ... and 57% of those who had voted in the TAFF race
over here. What with feelings running so high, and all the talk of withdrawing
from TAFF and setting up an alternative fund, it was beginning to look as if
TAFF couldn't survive a Beck victory. As TAFF administrator, I was faced with a
serious quandary. I hadn't been elected to preside over the dissolution of the
fund, the destruction of a worthy cause that had endured more than three
decades, but could the wishes of a British fandom that had so unequivocally
stated its position in this matter be ignored? Whoever won, this was going to be
the most crucial race in TAFF's history.
The voting deadline was midnight on 31st December 1984, and the next day the
votes were tallied. The final count said it all. In North America, Martha Beck
received 183 votes and the Nielsen Haydens 144, while over here the figures were
6 and 117 respectively, which meant the Nielsen Haydens defeated Beck by 261
votes to 189 (both the largest TAFF vote in the UK ever, and the largest
overall). It also spelt an end to the feud as far as most of the antagonists
were concerned. However, that one half of TAFF thought it was possible to be
disenfranchised by a group in the other, and that such acrimony could be
generated by something intended to improve the links of friendship between our
two fandoms, showed that the TAFF rules were in serious need of another
overhaul. Ironically, I'd seen the danger of something like this happening and
had proposed a couple of changes shortly after assuming office. Unfortunately,
Avedon vetoed these because Bergeron had just begun his attacks on her and she
thought that any tinkering with the rules at that point would have just given
him another excuse to pillory her. I'd proposed introducing a requirement that
in order to win a candidate must secure 25% of the vote in the host country, and
was in favour of dropping the write-in vote option, an American electoral
tradition rather than a British one which, in the context of TAFF, had always
seemed merely a way of avoiding the nomination requirements. Both Avedon and the
Nielsen Haydens thought the latter would be too difficult to sell to US fandom
but a version of the former, modified to the requirement that a winning
candidate must secure 20% of the vote on both sides of the Atlantic, was
accepted. This proposal was incorporated into the TAFF rules after being
ratified at a meeting of current administrators, previous administrators, and
founding fathers of TAFF that took place in Leeds at the 1985 Eastercon, the UK
National Convention. Greg Pickersgill won the next UK to US race (defeating
Judith Hanna and Simon Ounsley) and he too suffered attacks from certain US fans
both during and after the race. The pretext usually given for these attacks was
that he had written a piece in 1981 in STOP BREAKING DOWN #7 criticising the
contemporary state of TAFF. However, since most of the attacks came from those
he'd opposed by helping to organise the protest petition during the 1985 race,
people thoroughly discredited in the eyes of most British fans, they were
largely ignored over here. And so the TAFF Wars came, finally, to an end.
... from The Story So Far, Rob Hansen, 1987